You are browsing the archive for Discussion.

Notes from the TT/Occupy workshop at the VBC

06/27/2012 in Discussion

Notes from the TT/Occupy workshop at the VBC facilitated by Josh Schlossberg and Heather Pipino
Sunday, June 24, 2012 | Brookfield, VT

Words, Descriptions, Missions, Issues of the two groups:

Transition Town:
* Finding ways for communities around the world to adapt to climate change and peak oil; addressing how we live)
* Energy – Peak Oil
* Food – Permaculture (i.e. statehouse garden)
* Consumption issues, recycling, waste
* Natural resources (soil, water, air)
* Transportation
* DIY (“do it yourself”)
* Bridge to local government
* Time banks
* Responsible society
* Loosely organized
* Culture of sharing
* Local, small scale
* Re-skilling (growing, canning, composting)
* Intergenerational component
* Inevitability of future adaptation
* Environment / land-based
* Individual-centered, lifestyle, individual preparation

Occupy:
* Many leaders (a.k.a. leaderless)
* 99%-to-1% specifically about vast inequality, concentration of wealth
* Confronting the banking, monetary system — impacts of housing/foreclosure (6,300/day), corporate control of government
* Participatory style of democracy, direct democracy, consensus or modified consensus
* Public space / commons
* Using direct action to confront the system, engage people
* Theatrics
* Education, sharing knowledge and skills, workshops/teach-ins
* Urban based (?) — certainly more effective in urban area, but rural occupations too; difference of scale. Are there urban TT’s, or is it just rural?
* Diversity of tactics – violence / non-violence; systemic violence; police response
* Protest movements — anti-war, labor
* Social structures / human structures / oppression
* Suspicious of “organization” – inherent paranoia due to failure of systems and structures, fear of “co-option” by unions, political parties, or other groups (i.e. a “democratic tea party”)
* Inevitability of further economic “collapse” under capitalism / status quo
* Socially-centered, collective preparation

Similarities / Cross-Over:
* Ecology – Economy
* Decentralized – Local
* Basic fairness, equality, social and/or ecological relationships — only a few people create this imbalance
* Critical of destructive systems
* The Commons — i.e. public sphere
* Weakness = “fringe” — both want to attract more people, not be fringe
* Challenge power structures – bring power to people
* Opportunity = Good cop / Bad cop
* Live “off the grid” (i.e. not tied to oppressive systems, ways of doing things)
* Skeptical of political systems | Lack of political power
* Prefigurative model — live the way we must in the future
* Education and training — preparing ourselves individually and collectively for the economic and environmental crisis (i.e. the revolution)
* Analysis based on the economic-environmental crises
* Both willing to risk discomfort
* See corporate / capitalist model has failed (i.e. common enemy)
* Both have perceptions to overcome

Next Steps:
* Both want to attract more folks – reach out to others
* Both need to overcome perceptions (i.e. less “hippie” or “hipster”) without compromising who we are
* Interested in collaborating with others to get more people involved (BG)
* Ways to have more dialogue, explore commonalities, flush these things out more (HP)
* Hemp issue (JS) [joked about it being a 'nail in the coffin' on the 'hippie' thing]

Avatar of Yeshua

by Yeshua

Invitation: Saturday’s Occupy Central VT Event

06/26/2012 in Discussion, GET UP GET OUT!, Next GA location & agenda, Trainings & Skill Shares

Next Saturday, June 30, Occupy meeting at Margaret’s house

1-3 p.m.: Come early to hang out, hike, lie in the hammock, problem solve (I’ll provide some problems), nap, play badminton, pick flowers, do artwork, etc.

(It’s supposed to be a sunny, warm day–so this slightly cooler spot might have some appeal, especially for those picketing at the farmer’s market
in the morning.)

Children, significant others, family members are most welcome to come along, and join in discussion (or not), supper, campfire, etc..  Toys,
beds, and childcare available.

3-5 p.m.: Occupy discussion:

  • 15 minutes:  reflection and evaluation of our part in the Convergence
  • 15 minutes:  July pop-up:  when, where, and what (DAWG)
  • 90 minutes:  What is a Movement? (facilitated by Margaret); an overview of social movements in our lifetimes and how we envision the Occupy Movement.

5-7 p.m.:  pot-luck supper (I’ll provide some potato salad, brownies, and apple juice)

7 on:  campfire (an opportunity for informal sharing, music, etc.)–help initiate my new fire pit.

Camping overnight is also an option if you want to bring your own tents and sleeping bags.

(You might also want to bring bug spray, and other outdoor protections, as well as folding chairs if you have one–if not, I have some chairs
here).

P.S. I have two dogs and two cats, but we will meet in a fur-free room if you have allergies.

 

Please contact tech[at]occupycentralvt.org for directions and/or additional contact info.

Post rideshare requests in the comments below, or speak up on the discussion email list.

 

Avatar of Yeshua

by Yeshua

Minutes from OCVT Action & Gathering Saturday, June 16th, 2012

06/19/2012 in Art WG, Direct Action WG, Discussion, Education & Empowerment WG, GA Minutes, GET UP GET OUT!, Pop-Up Occupations, Teach-In, Trainings & Skill Shares

Minutes from Working Group meet up in Montpelier

Note: small group present, rather than break out into separate working groups, we chose to form a single group discussion

Present: Sue, Margaret, Marie, John, Dell, Diane, Christian, Mark, Cheyenne, Colin, Yeshua

Note: Open agenda / stack taken

Margaret’s informal proposal

  • for the last Saturday of June (6/30) – to meet @ her house in W. Topsham, 3-5pm, with a pot luck dinner afterwards
  • Ask Facilitation Working Group for help organizing: get word out & coordinate rides
  • proposed topic for discussionwhat is a movement?

Education & Empowerment – open to topics for July’s Teach-in

some options..

  • Kate’s Thesis (notes missed topic, sorry..)
  • movie screening, suggestions: Made in Dagenham, Margin Call, Inside Job

Direct Action Working Group – Today’s Action @ Citizen’s Bank

  • 11am on Saturday @ Citizen’s on Main St in Montpelier – very few customers
  • we went to the Farmer’s market instead, handed out a lot of fliers and engaged people for discussion – far more fruitful
  • Our current plan to proceed:
    • Friday, 4-5pm @ Citizen’s Bank – see if foot traffic is higher / makes more sense?
    • Saturday, 11am-12pm @ Farmer’s Market – every Saturday for now on – mic-check / speak-outs / poetry jam / engage people

Next Week is the Village Building Convergence – Occupiers will join forces with Transition Towners for 2 days of workshops and fun!

Next Pop-up Occupation – where & when?

Plainfield – issue: Biomass Plant @ Goddard

oh, by the way… while we’re on this topic..

  • planned & announced without consultation with neighbors
  • there is an Act 250 meeting coming up, has been postponed and not yet rescheduled
  • we seem to be in support of the community, but maybe we should research the history of this issue some more and possibly write a statement of support for the neighbors & greater Plainfield community, to be submitted to Act 250
  • any takers? – Yeshua offered to write up first draft
  • John may also have some information on contacts, will share with Yeshua

Barre – Occupy Barre is meeting this coming Tuesday 6/19 @ 5pm in front of City Hall – discuss here first

Marshfield – Issue: poverty – Food Shelf need is on the rise (like 5x a few years ago..)

possible workshops / talks:

  • Food Shelf Experience – Marshfield Coordinator
  • Food Sovereignty – Yeshua
  • Time Banking / Gift Economies – maybe Marie w/ others?

where in Marshfield is an open question, options aren’t the best
Decisions will be futher solidified after meeting up with Occupy Barre - we need representatives to go to their meeting!

 

OCVT Parade Presences:

  • July 3rd in Montpelier @6pm
  • July 4th in Cabot (morning)
  • ENCOURAGE INVOLVEMENT!

Discussion Theme: Where Do We Go From Here?

05/30/2012 in Discussion, Education & Empowerment WG

The Occupy movement arose in response to the global financial and economic crisis as a self-organized opposition to the rising socio-economic inequality, and the corporate domination and corruption of our politics and government that caused the debacle. Yet despite the continuing crisis and committed efforts, OCVT has experienced declining attendance at its GAs and apparently waning energies. This Saturday 6/2 from 3-4PM the Education & Empowerment WG will facilitate an open forum discussion on the “nature” of organizing, what our aims are or should be, and how we can get our group back on track and re-energized. Please join us for a vigorous, no-holds-barred discussion! (however, stack will be taken). As always, you are welcome to post any comments or relevant materials in the comments section below.

Discussion Theme: The Banking System 5/19 at 3PM

05/16/2012 in Discussion, Education & Empowerment WG

Please join us Saturday, May 19th from 3-4PM for a discussion on the U.S. banking system. John Halasz will offer a brief compressed account of the workings of capitalist banking and credit, how it generates credit/debt without quite depending on a prior pool of savings/loanable funds. Additionally, we’ll look at how, even though banks compete with each other, they are tightly inter-connected and leveraged as a system and individually. Finally, John will explain how they operate through maturity transformation, borrowing short and cheap, and lending longer term at higher rates.

This trifecta creates a banking system that is prone to runs, panics, and financial crises, which requires supports and regulations to work “properly.”  When credit and debt out-run the productive and income-generating capacities of the real economy, the banks find new ways to evade their regulatory capital requirements through off balance sheet vehicles and lending to leveraged financial businesses outside the scope of official regulations, thus further leveraging the financial system (and loading the real economy with debt) through what has been called the “shadow banking system.”

Jay Moore will then briefly discuss the rising concentration of U.S. banking over the last 30+ years and the post-crisis/post-bailout policy of “regulatory forbearance,” a.k.a. extend and pretend. Heather Pipino will then briefly introduce legislative efforts to form a VT state-owned public bank. May a lively discussion then ensue!

For your consideration here are some background materials:

A business news article on how the largest banks post-crisis are dominating business lending: http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052970204062704577221091577249300.html

A commentary by Simon Johnson, a former IMF economist, on the recent Obama administration “settlement”, (i.e. coverup),  with the major banks for malfeasance in mortgage servicing: http://www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/too-big-to-jail

An earlier longer article by the same fellow on the bank bailouts and the capture of the political system by Wall St.: http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2009/05/the-quiet-coup/7364/

A chart of the consolidation of the 4 largest U.S. banks today since 1990: http://www.democracyindistress.com/2011/10/bank-consolidation-chart.html

And an article on a state owned public bank: http://www.ilsr.org/how-state-banks-bring-money-home/

Feel free to add further informative links in the comments section below.

Avatar of Yeshua

by Yeshua

Discussion & General Assembly 3-5PM on 05/04/2012

05/04/2012 in Discussion, Facilitation WG, Next GA location & agenda

Occupy Central VT’s next General Assembly is Saturday, May 4th from 3-5PM

 

We will continue outside again this Saturday, in front of City Hall in Montpelier. We will start with a discussion session - National Security State / Full Spectrum Dominance - from 3-4pm, with a 1 hour General Assembly following from 4-5pm. See the General Assembly Agenda below for more details.

 

Discussion: National Security State (facilitated by Education & Empowerment): Please join us for a discussion on the theme of the National Security State in the Context of Full Spectrum Dominance, the implications for political protest, and our responsibility as Americans living within the empire.

 

Agenda for the General Assembly

  • Intro – 10 min – call for next weeks volunteers
  • Occupy Vermont Report Back/Share – 20 min
    • Celebrate!!!!
    • Debrief and Report Back from march/rally/tabling [plus/delta/insight]
    • Debrief and Report Back about GA from others [plus/delta/insight]
  • Working Group Reports Back – 5-10 min
  • Working Group Break Out Time – 20 min (rally up and check in about Occupy Pop-In, not just for Direct Action Working Group to make successful
  • Announcements – 5-10 min

This week, serving our General Assembly will be: Yeshua (facilitation), Amy (stack), Jay (notes), Heather (props and facilitation), Steven (greeter/welcome), and Colin (de-escalation).

Discussion Theme: National Security State-Full Spectrum Dominance

05/03/2012 in Discussion, Education & Empowerment WG

The Occupy Wall Street encampments and protests have exposed the increased militarization of the police and heightened national security state. Protestors engaged in nonviolent direct action have been met with random and/or mass arrests, chemical weapons, and police brutality. OWS has lifted the curtain on an alarmingly militarized domestic police force, in line and supported by U.S. policy for global full-spectrum dominance.

Recent laws such as CISPA (Cyber Intelligence Sharing and Protection Act), H.R. 347 (Federal Restricted Buildings and Grounds Improvement Act), and changes to NDAA (National Defense Authorization Act) have generated controversy over the implications for abuse of Presidential authority, illegal surveillance, and dangerous infringements on our constitutional rights.

What OWS is experiencing today has direct ties to prior U.S. history of the Cold War and McNamara’s “ladder of escalation,” which has built total U.S. global military dominance in direct relationship to U.S. global economic “interests.” We’ll introduce a brief background history to explore the basic question: What is this excrescent U.S. “national security state,” what sort of “security” does it seek to maintain, and in whose “interests”? Is the U.S. now actually only in an arms race with itself?. And how does it effect us, as citizens, members of the U.S. population, both in relation to how we view and understand our domestic society and how we understand (or not) the “outside” world?

Please join us for a discussion on the theme of the National Security State in the Context of Full Spectrum Dominance, the implications for political protest, and our responsibility as Americans living within the empire.

Saturday, May 5th from 3-4PM (before the General Assembly) outside City Hall in Montpelier.

There is a host of articles and resources on this subject.
Please feel free to add more resources and information in the comments section below.

Discussion Theme: Populism

04/12/2012 in Discussion, Education & Empowerment WG

Occupy Wall Street has been described by some astute observers as a sort — perhaps a brand-new 21st century sort — of “populist” movement. (See the “Dissent” article.) Populism, a term with classical Latin roots, has had many historical permutations. There have been populisms both on the Left and on the Right. But the basic common denominator of populism is that of posing “the people” (however that term may be defined) and their broad public interests against those of an economic or cultural elite which, it is argued, is pursuing its own particular and selfish interests. Thus, the 99% vs. the 1%.

In U.S. history, the most important populist movement – indeed, arguably the U.S. social-change movement with the biggest and broadest appeal of any  kind ever – took place during the 1890s. Farmers (at that time the vast majority of the U.S. population), joined by some industrial workers and small  businessmen and an assortment of reformers rose up in anger against the power of the new privately-owned economic monopolies like the railroads. In doing so, these populists created a whole kind of “movement culture” with their own institutions and established a political party, the People’s Party, to run against the Dems. and Reps. (who were perceived to be controlled by the “interests”). The latter was short-lived. But the movement as a whole had some real successes in transforming the public discourse – opening up a democratic conversation – and in laying the ground for Progressive reforms.

Our discussion this Saturday will look at this populist history and what if any lessons for our own movement can be learned from it pro and con. We can also explore, if conversation goes that way, the differences between right-wing populism (as exemplified by the contemporary Tea Party) and left-wing  populism (as exemplified – if that is what in fact it is – by ourselves in OWS).

For the discussion, please review the resources provided (and please feel free to add more in the comments below!):

Avatar of Yeshua

by Yeshua

May Day Discussion & General Assembly – 03.31.2012

04/05/2012 in Discussion, Education & Empowerment WG, GA Minutes

Discussion Theme from 3-4PM:

General Assembly Agenda from 4-5PM:

 

 

General Strike and MayDay Discussion

3/31/2012

 

Let’s start this discussion with a framing question: What would a General Strike look like? In our communities, etc

Deorscha: I have no boss to strike against, I’m a poor, self-employed carpenter struggling to pay my bills

Irvin: how would this look like for local businesses – are we refusing to shop locally? With jobs tough to maintain/etc, is this a risk.

Traven: this is about power, fundamentally. The electoral process is broken, you can have millions protest and they’ll ignore you – you have to do something cause problems for the system to get attention – strike is about getting ot the heart of the capitalist system – we work together, support one another in gathering together for a strike. Why is this relevant? There’s an international mass strike phenomenon. We’re part of a larger movement.

Yeshua:

Amy: I’m not seeing this as all or nothing – we need to do what we can do. Plainfield co-op has a board that doesn’t want to close the store, while the workers do, so closing for part of the time with

Heather: more and more people are atomized, working in places where it impossible to organize – retail for example – concerted effort from capitalist society to break labor and keep us separate. All I have to offer as an individual (to the system) is time and energy, my work, so it’s the only thing – people died, and gave themselves to this movement, that we take for granted. GET EVERYONE OUT, to everyone who doesn’t have a union to join, we need to give back to the labor movement and embolden the movement. What would I share with a local shop keeper – think about all the hardship you suffer under, 365 days a year, every year, so for one day, stand up for yourself and take a couple hours off to close down in protest of the larger system.

Deorscha: how do we get the big guys, like Fairpoint, Vermont Yankee, National Life, etc..

Renee: Deorscha has been expressing what I have been thinking, in some way. I do a radio show on Tuesdays, I would love to have a few of you on. I’m part of the Vermont Writer’s Union, I’ll check in with them. How do we expand the education to things like All Species Day, or spreading & expanding the network? Be a laboring species out on All Species

Charlotte: this is a bit early in America, in some ways.. workers == socialist communism. Cart before the horse? But we should definitely educate. How do we attack this problem of imagery, and the battle against “the worker”

Cecile: feel the need and pull for equity and our capacity to work, what it means “to be employed” or a “worker” – totally behind the symbolism behind a May Day Strike – so many have died for this. What do we do beyond this? How do we define what it means to be a worker? How do we break through this enslavement, how do we reach people in the machine, how do we expand the network? What if we had “an operating system” that when installed in an organization, give power back to the workers, generating profit for those who run the organization/organism. This OS produces more profit, but what it delivers is worker equality. This is a trojan horse :)

Jim: negative connotation around May Day, strikes, and even anything remotely close to sharing. For this to succeed, I believe we need to reach the middle class, there needs to be an understanding of what equity, community, etc all are – gift economies

Marie: capture the middle class. They’re not living anymore, we’re all going down..educating the middle class – get them angry. Our march and rally in town would serve well to this effect. Let’s start distributing info before hand, the week + (to stores and local peoples).

Alice: I’m retired, I don’t have a union, but I want to help and participate / support with others. What are unions doing?

Traven: local unions and organizing bodies have been working at this, but we don’t have a culture of a general strike. We’ve shut down cities with general strikes, as part of this we identify what is really important to human beings. To have an extended general strike, you have to have this infrastructure in formation – getting people out is a big part of creating this path

Robert: glad you’re all here, I haven’t been able to plug into Occupy recently, so thank you. How do we build a general understanding that “we’re all in this together”. Burlington Vermont ‘wobblies’ chapter of a union that could be shutdown due to lack of membership – we, those that don’t have a union can join the IWW

Marie: we need to be conscious of our words, let’s stop using the term middle-class.

John: we want to revive the sense of “being all together” as the working class, maybe termed differently.Part of reviving may day is helping union movement broaden, embolden, etc – we can do what they can’t.

 

What role can Occupy play?

Brian: bring some of these fliers around to local shop owners, many whom we know. Let’s also think through what other aspects of this day will look like. Worker’s Center has done a lot, but it’s also on Occupy to figure out the rest of what’s gonna go on. In the next few weeks, we need to think these things through.

Heather: in terms of what we can do in this area: hang up some of the general strike posters we have in shop fronts and work with them to develop a statement to help educate people. Montpelier may be small, but it’d be pretty cool if we did shut down at least parts of it. Until we have a consicousness of people who felt they could take on something larger than themselves (like targeting walmart). Getting someone like national life on strike might be more difficult, small strikes still build revolutions.

Amy: want to propose: 6 schools in this region – some of you know teachers – let’s bring a busload of students and teachers! Please join me in helping to make this happen. Students aren’t getting this in their history class.

Kelly: general reminder : E&E leads discussions each week, we like suggestions, and people joining us.

 

 General Assembly – 03.31.2012

Facilitation: Cecile, Colin

Notes: Yeshua

General Assembly Agenda from 4-5PM:

 

Notes:

  • Introductions / Review & Consense on Agenda
    • review proposal process:
      • proposer proposes
      • discuss – info, clarifying questions, concern / discussion
      • Brief amend round – chance for proposer to change / amend
      • Consense – we can each: stand aside, yes/love it, neutral, down hands/concerned, block
    • agenda & facilitation team – consense
  • WG Reports Back
    • Direct Action:
      • talked a lot about our popup-occupy – day long sessions in communities
      • aim to do two before VBC (Village Building Convergence)
      • fleshed out some vision & specific components
      • Bethany working on a more formalized / structured plan
      • meeting Tuesdays @ 6pm – next is in person – Bethany point
    • Basic Needs – Irvin
      • coffee hour is starting back up
      • Heather: can we stay outside for this? Whenever it is nice
        • Irvin: sure! We’ll coordinate with facilitation
    • Education & Empowerment – Kelly
      • NDAA
      • teach in – 3-5pm – Patriarchy and Oppression
      • working on an Occupy Library – looking for donations
      • April 14th, lots going on – 99% Spring NVDA Training
        • show of hands for full day NVDA Training – 22nd
        • train the trainer
      • meeting times – Fridays 6pm – hit or miss. Kelly / Heather point
    • Finance – Yeshua
      • there are 3 of us, 2 are on a trip
    • Facilitation – Cecile
      • mostly ongoing GA agendas
      • Thursdays 6pm – Cecile on point
  • WG Proposals
    • DAWG – Adhoc Postal WG
      • proposal: would like OCVT GA to endorse a letter we have to send/share with the postal service
      • April 17thmass leafletting at post offices
        • if you want to help, connect with Traven / Heather
      • we’ve been working with postal works WRJ
        • they’re being told it’s a done deal and that if they step out of line they will lose their job.
        • so we decided to write a letter to let them know they’re not alone – “you are not alone” is the central message.
      • Jim Hightower wrote a good article about what’s really going on
        • TODO: look up and get it posted as a comment to the original post with this letter
      • weekly conf calls Sunday nights
      • consense: all twinkles
    • Facilitation WG: statements drafted for Occupy Vermont – we have a responsibility to review, update/amend (if necessary)
    • the statements:
    • proposal: discuss this statement, consense on our acceptance of this
    • these statements received provisional acceptance at our first statewide GA @ Goddard March 10th
    • these “came” from Occupy Wall Street, but have been updated/adapted for us
    • both statements were read and notes shared about comments made at the OVT GA
    • discussion:
      • clarifying questions / info / input for potential amendments:
        • John: what do we mean by “individuals’ inherent privilege”?
          • Heather: refers to the inherent privileges given at birth (i.e. white, male, hetero, etc.)
        • Fallon: remove the extract wealth within it’s statement to make it more general -
        • Brian: “the system must protect our rights” – we have an economic system which is inherently incapable of protecting our rights.
        • Renee – add reverence for life
        • RE Brian’s comment – system is not general enough, political is too specific, I would say “cultural system”. #2: “inherent social privilege”.
        • Amy: point about
        • Kelly: important to me to keep the note about privilege
      • Heather: what is our process on working on this? We have to get this out to other Occupy groups before statewide GA for them to review / consider / incorporate / etc.
        • Cecile: how do we keep this from being an endless process. Method of object – what would cause harm about this statement – and anyone can bring a proposal forward. I’d love to see this go through the GA next week and have it changed if it needs
        • Fallon: maybe add “on this day” so this is noted as a “from now” and going forward
  • Announcements/New WG formations
    • Kelly: April 28th, Women’s Rights Rally – State House – speakers @
      • starting Women’s Rights working group – Kelly point
    • Brian: WG & Annoucement
      • VBC (June 24th) – we’ve got a WG forming, taking input for workshops and other stuff to do – we have all of Sunday
      • trying to keep this focused on Occupy -
      • Francis Fox Piven coming to Vermont – historian on poor people’s movements, attacked by Glenn Beck/etc, Thursday night Davis Center @ UVM April 12th
    • Amy: Teacher’s in Barre working on agreements,
      • presence of teachers turned the board – they didn’t want to see us walk
    • Irvin: 2 bills @ statehouse – philosophical \ require labeling GMOs
      • Death by Medicine: first meta-study on medically caused deaths / injury